Freight trains stopped running on the Seminole Gulf Railway line through Bonita Springs in 2008. The rails are still there. They run past the Wonder Gardens and Arts Bonita, over Spring Creek and beside Railhead Scrub Preserve, inside a corridor that is generally 130 feet wide. Bonita Springs voters agreed on August 18 to pay for turning that strip into the Bonita Estero Rail Trail. WGCU reported that the measure passed with 68 percent support on 21 percent turnout.
For the small group of homes and parcels whose land touches the corridor, the vote raises a property-rights question. Part of the land under those tracks may never have belonged to the railroad.
The strip behind the fence may be a borrowed one
The Seminole Gulf right-of-way was put together in the late 1800s, when the line belonged to the Seaboard railroad. WGCU's July 3 report described it as a patchwork. The railroad bought some sections outright. In others, landowners only granted an easement.
Congress added a rail-to-trail provision to the National Trails System Act in 1983.
The federal step is already underway. On July 1, 2026, Trust for Public Land asked the Surface Transportation Board for a Notice of Interim Trail Use covering the 11.4-mile corridor and said it was willing to take on management, liability and tax responsibilities under railbanking. That request followed a Federal Register notice on Seminole Gulf's abandonment exemption, which set July 6 as the deadline for trail-use requests.
WGCU reported that as many as 50 landowners could be eligible to seek compensation. The St. Louis firm Lewis Rice, which has handled these claims in Sarasota, Pinellas and Miami-Dade counties, had about 12 clients at the time. Some earlier clients dropped out when the sale changed the trail boundaries slightly. Attorney Lindsay Brinton told WGCU that she estimated the litigation lasts about two years.
Sarasota already put a dollar figure on this
The closest Florida example runs about an hour north. In 2004, the Surface Transportation Board authorized a rail-to-trail conversion of a 12.43-mile Sarasota County line that became the Legacy Trail. A Court of Federal Claims opinion later set compensation for 13 properties that abut it.
| Legacy Trail case | Amount |
|---|---|
| Plaintiffs asked for | $8,703,800 |
| Federal government argued for | $2,220,900 |
| Court awarded for the land under the 50-foot trail easement | $4,706,047.56 |
| Court awarded in severance damages | $995,532.17 |
| Total award | $5,701,579.73 |
In that case, the severance award covered harm to the rest of the properties, beyond the strip itself. The 13 properties were three golf courses, four single-family homes, four vacant lots, a subdivision under development and an automobile salvage yard. Owners whose homes back onto the trail testified that noise, traffic, trespass and property damage all increased. The plaintiffs submitted analyses showing that properties next to a corridor were worth 16 to 28 percent less than properties away from it. That range came from the plaintiffs, and the court did not adopt it as a finding. The court record also cites Sarasota County's estimate that 125,000 to 140,000 people use the trail each year, which helps explain the testimony.
Owners didn't all respond the same way. Gulfshore Business reported attorneys saying that some Legacy Trail clients put their compensation back into the project. Others opposed a trail behind their homes, and some supported the trail but didn't want it next door.
How Bonita Springs is paying for the trail
For most owners in the city, the vote shows up as a tax line. The ballot authorized up to $35 million in Bonita Springs general-obligation bonds to buy and build the trail. The bonds mature within 30 years and are repaid from ad valorem property taxes. Gulfshore Business reported a city staff estimate of $4.75 a month, or $57 a year, for an average home.
Gulfshore Business reported how the $60 million purchase from Seminole Gulf Railway is split. Bonita Springs pays $28.6 million for its 5.8 miles, Estero pays $19.8 million and Collier County pays $11.6 million. Trust for Public Land buys the corridor and hands each government its piece.
The calendar runs longer than the vote suggests
Timing matters for anyone buying or selling along the corridor, because the purchase, the federal process, track removal and construction all have different schedules.
| When | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1987 | Seminole Gulf acquires the line from CSX |
| 2008 | Last freight operations |
| June 26, 2026 | Federal Register publishes the abandonment-exemption notice |
| July 1, 2026 | Trust for Public Land files its trail-use request with the STB |
| August 18, 2026 | Bonita Springs voters approve the bonds |
| October 28, 2026 | Estero Village Council votes unanimously to proceed with closing |
| January 14, 2027 | Targeted closing of the $60 million purchase |
| Up to two years after closing | Seminole Gulf removes the tracks while design work proceeds |
| After that | A construction period of roughly 12 to 24 months, possibly opened in phases |
Estero's October 28 vote came after a two-phase environmental study by S&S Environmental Consultants, which tested 180 soil samples at 60 locations. Gulfshore Business reported that the study found elevated arsenic and polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons at several points in Estero, Bonita Springs and Collier County. Arsenic exceeded study limits north of Corkscrew Road and just east of Coconut Point Mall. Guri Zeigerman of Apex Companies, who reviewed the findings for Estero, called the levels "very typical." The proposed fixes follow what Sarasota used on the Legacy Trail, including concrete caps at trailheads and mixing clean soil into the shoulder.
According to WINK News, the mayor estimated it would be more than two years before major physical changes, followed by about a year of construction. For a buyer closing on a home next to the corridor this winter, the first few years of ownership could include track removal and then construction, with the finished trail coming after that.
What sits along Bonita's 5.8 miles
The BERT project map shows several landmarks on the downtown 34135 stretch. Arts Bonita and the Wonder Gardens are directly east of the future trail, with a planned connection to the Wonder Gardens. Railhead Scrub Preserve is directly west. The route crosses Spring Creek, Oak Creek and the Estero River, and it borders Coconut Point Mall farther north. Seminole Gulf's federal filing counts 18 public-road crossings across the full 11.4 miles, which runs from Estero Parkway south to the planned extension of Wiggins Pass Road.
Questions for a home that backs onto the tracks
From a buyer's side of the table, these are the questions that come up with a corridor-adjacent listing:
- How might a few years of track removal and construction affect the plans for the property, whether it's a seasonal home, a rental or a full-time residence?
- On the other side, how close is the nearest planned trailhead or connection, given that the Legacy Trail case drew testimony about both foot traffic and trespass?
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Questions about title, takings claims or contract terms belong with a real estate attorney or title professional who can review your specific parcel.
Is the corridor purchase final?
As of Estero's October 28 vote, all three governments had approved moving forward, and closing is targeted for January 14, 2027.
Beach to Bunker Properties can walk you through what corridor-adjacent homes are trading for and what a few years of track removal and construction next door could mean for a sale. Start with a number grounded in today's market. Get Your Instant Property Valuation.